I think this is very interesting. Ever since George's TeaTime explaining the 3 lots of metal purchased for caps, I've been curious as to what happened in recent years.
George said there was an original batch... a second batch in early '18 from a different supplier, and a 3rd batch from the OG supplier.
Early caps were nice and hot. Reading a 5-6 gain ratio on older caps was quite normal. Combustion from these caps too was a convection issue as it always lit a coal in the middle of the load.
My first dud was a 2020 cap. A gain ratio of 2.75:1 wasn't cutting it. Combined with the airy tip, it made for my first suck experience with my Dynavap. It was sold soon thereafter.
Here comes early '22 and new materials arrived. I didn't give my 419 caps and a standard cap any attention since ordering them at the 419 sale. But when George mentioned that these were from the OG supplier, my ears perked up.
I finally did the gain ratio test. For those who have only heard the term, this is how the cap interacts with the induction heater. An induction heater that draws 1 amp when idle (no cap) and draws 2.75 amps with the cap is a cap that has a gain ratio of 2.75:1, for instance.
Moving forward, and how this relates to Simrell's FMJ sleeve, and
@Demonic chronic 's observations are based on older hotter caps as are mine with some early testing with 'sleeves'. Turns out that the recent 419 caps and the standard cap from the shop all came in at a whopping GR of 5.3:1! These caps are the caps of yesteryear. Full extraction in 2 draws, no problem.
This is what I was all on about over the past year or so. George made the point very well at TeaTime. I don't know that he got it but he finally understood that the metal's reaction to induction heaters varies. Well, they should vary a little but not as much as in recent years. From sheet to sheet, there is a difference. Hopefully they are closer to the same thing from cap to cap and sheet to sheet this time.
I'm still all in favor of binning the caps. Not tossing them, but binning them to performance levels. George doesn't seem to have caught onto the fact that when it reacts differently in the IH, it also tends to hold heat better with a torch. There is a huge difference in performance when you see the various gain ratios and how they perform.
Are we going to see wild variation with this lot of material? I don't know. But I am more than happy with my 419 purchase as these are the caps I've sought for some time now.