Shiz said:
stonemonkey55 said:
@shiz - I think that it is a misnomer when people say that a certain piece is overkill for vaping and would be better served as a combustion piece. To me, if I take a big enough rip out of my Pillar, I will still cough. This tells me that the vapor can be even smoother. I think the question you should ask yourself is, "Do I enjoy using this type of waterpipe?" If the answer is yes, then by all means, use that particular waterpipe.
The general consensus seems to be that it's possible to over-diffuse vapor. From your personal experience you disagree with that? I trying to get more specifics to learn the mechanics and diffusion differences between all these tubes and the most effective, efficient methods of using them with vapor or smoke.
Aesthetics aside, there has to be specific differences in draw, diffusion, taste and overall experience between the 60mm, the 12 arm, the pillar (and other diffusion styles) that I can learn and benefit from. I'm an Amazon review reader type...I try to absorb as much info as possible from other consumers like me and make the best purchases I can based on thorough feedback.
If you guys get bored one day and have some extra time, try to see if you can be very specific and tell us how these pieces in particular perform compared to another. I'm sure there's more we can learn from all your experience if you had extra time and really wanted to make some thorough comparisons and reviews. There's nothing like a good thorough review from a source you consider reliable.
@shiz - I think the general consensus that you can over diffuse vapor is due to the fact that vapor is already smoother than smoke. When I started vaporizing back in 97, the thought of even just using a bong to run your vapor through it was considered overkill. Then when people started adding ice to their bongs, there was another group that said it was overkill. Now the arguement is multiple percs is overkill with vapor, I beleive with time, this opinion will change as well.
The funny thing is, 9 times out of 10, the people that tell me that a certain piece is overkill for vapor are people that have never even used a high end glass piece to vape through. I'm just generalizing here but if anyone is old enough to remember the Sega versus Nintendo console wars back inthe 80s, Nintendo fan boys would say Nintendo was better, while Sega fanboys would stand behind their product. Most of the Nintendo fanboys never even had a chance to play Sega, yet they supported the fact that Nintendo was a superior machine with as much conviction as possible.
I was thinking of different ways to try and describe the experience of these different pieces and it will take a better writer than myself to do so. It is like skydiving, if you have never skydived before, it is hard to understand the true experience of jumping out of a plane, feeling the air rush passed your face, finally hitting terminal velocity, feeling that feeling of bliss, etc etc without actually having skydived before.
A lot of people will say that this piece over diffuses, or this piece takes out all of the flavor, this piece looks like it will have too much drag before even taking a hit. I think we all have a little bit of the "amazon review" person in us where we want to know more about a particular experience before purchasing a piece. I think reading all this gives us pre-conceived notions of how something is supposed to hit/feel/diffuse, and when you have these pre-conceived notions, I often feel like this takes away from the true experience of hitting a piece.
For me, to find out if I really, really like a piece, or if I have been influenced by what I read, I like to vape with a buddy who will blind fold me and hand me different pieces to take hits off of. This way, I have no idea if it is a low end piece, high end piece, multiple chambers, etc etc and make up my mind with a blind vape test. With these blind vapor tests, I've seen some high end pieces get lower scores and vice versa.
Shiz, my recommendation for you is to try to find some people with pieces that you like. After trying those, at least you will have a baseline to compare different experiences to. This would be analagous to taking a test drive, once you test drive a Porsche/Honda/Ferrari etc etc - then it will be easier for you to get a understanding of how a certain piece hits. For example, to me a SGW Waffle hits similarlly to a SG Stemline with slightly more drag and since it has a smaller bore, it clears quicker. Now Pappy is able to somewhat imagine what a Waffle will feel like in comparison to a Stemline.
I dunno if that explanation was helpful or not but I hope it was.