florduh
Well-Known Member
Shopping is important in a consumer economy, no doubt. But, economic activity includes working too.
Right. If people are shopping, travelling, eating out, there are workers there to serve them. Sorry if that wasn't clear.
As to people modifying behavior, hurrah! Freedom! People making choices based on their assessment of risk is the way it should be. If their freely chosen behaviors tanks the economy, it is theirs to tank. The problems develop when our betters take those choices away.
I'll just take the economy of my home State, Floriduh. Even if there were no shutdowns, our tourism economy was going to be screwed. Just a reduction in international travellers is enough to cause widespread layoffs. That spills over into the ancillary industries servicing hotels ,convention centers, theme parks etc. Our restaurants aren't shutdown right now. Every time I go to pick up take-out... they're mostly empty.
I keep going back to the half empty Trump rally. In Oklahoma. This is like Springsteen not selling out in Jersey. There were no shutdowns causing that. Just people deciding that congregating in large groups is too risky. Florida, our third largest State, only works when people congregate in large groups (conventions/theme parks).
We can't re-run history, but the idea that never shutting down would've saved the economy doesn't hold water, to me anyway.