How many of you folks who are talking about the military and what its made of have actually been in the military?
I have and I can tell you that the majority of those who volunteered to join the military back when I did "AS AN ENLISTED PERSON" versus an officer, (Enlisted folks are the majority of the boots on the ground and the majority of the boots under the ground.) joined because there was nothing else for them. They weren't going to college, couldn't afford college and their options for making a living were pretty slim. The number of enlisted personnel I came in contact with who joined because they love America and wanted to show their love by defending it with their life was pretty low. Once you're in the military it can be a different story in terms of fighting for and with your brothers. Also nobody gave a rats ass about politics or party. Most folks weren't even 20 yet.
If there was an invasion of American soil the above would change drastically and it wouldn't make a shits worth of difference which party you align with anymore than it did in peace time.
My nephew was considering going into the military and had plenty of other options. When I asked him why the military ....... He told me he wanted to prove to himself how tough he was and he didn't want to go to college. I told him joining the military to prove he was tough just proves how immature he is and he shouldn't join unless its because of his love for America and his willingness to give his life for his country.
I joined because I got in so much trouble that my options were join the military or go to jail according to the judge. Best thing that ever happened to me because once I scrubbed that 100th toilet the light went on in my head that I should use the GI Bill to go to college.
I suspect when you served and which branch makes a huge difference in your experience. I joined to protect my country from the Russians, Muslim terrorists and Iranians in 1979. I didnt know anyone who volunteered to escape thier circumstances. No matter how bad your life was most people didnt think joining the military and potentially lying somewhere while you bled out was an improvement in living conditions. People used to understand you join the military to close with the enemy and kill them....
Reading the news today, I'm not sure it made any difference since its still the exact same 3 problems were dealing with. Maybe its because I still see the same idiots running the show from here that were running things in 1979.
I also suspect when you served and which branch makes a difference... I can say post 9/11 at least, everybody I served with, was by choice, and for love of country. I honestly cannot think of one person that said, "I joined because I had no choice."
Post 9/11 especially, I think the days of the old judge looking at you, "Son, its the military or prison, the choice is yours..." are long gone. I think that went away decades ago. Now, it's actually very difficult to get into the military with any sort of legal issues on your record.
So yes I have seen how the military has changed over the years, from the inside, which was glaringly obvious when I decided to get out years ago.
Granted I also went into the USMC and I tend to think that those looking for whatever benefits they think they'll get would with an "easier" branch so maybe its different there and you'd find more people who "didn't have a choice."
Modnote: Edited to remove political content