What do you call it when the legal price goes up and the illegal (black market) goes down?
Canada.
One good thing is that legal is sure to come down by decree or market. For instance, the article lists an ounce of "Original Stash" for about a buck and a quarter. ($125.70 CA with taxes included.)
The gap between what Canadians pay for legal and illicit
cannabis is widening — a sign, experts say, points to the need for the
cannabis industry to make prices a priority this year.
Statistics Canada said Thursday that the average price of
legal cannabis increased to $10.30 per gram in the period between October and December 2019 from $9.69 per gram the year before.
The change came as the average price of
illegal cannabis fell to $5.73 per gram in that fourth quarter from $6.44 per gram a year earlier and as the overall average price of cannabis rose to $7.50 per gram, an increase from $7.46 per gram a year earlier.
The agency based its conclusions on price quotes gathered using its StatsCannabis crowdsourcing application between Oct. 1 and Dec. 31. Out of 291 price submissions, 248 of were deemed plausible, it said.
The data comes as the industry is grappling with how to minimize the underground cannabis market — one of the key reasons why the country chose to legalize
recreational cannabis in October 2018.
Some
dispensaries reported being busier than before in the months following
legalization, even as
police departments and governments conducted raids to force many illegal
cannabis stores to shut their doors. The industry’s efforts to stamp out the illicit market, however, have been plagued with supply constraints and in some regions, a lack of physical
cannabis retailers, hampering access for those unwilling or unlikely to buy the substance online.
“Legal cannabis has been priced much higher than the
black market ever since legalization day,” said Michael Armstrong, an associate professor at the
Goodman School of Business at Brock University in
Ontario.
“I think for any of the mass market producers, (price) has to be their objective for this year, if it hasn’t been already.”
In a bid to undercut the illict market, licensed producer Hexo Corp. rolled out Original Stash, a 28-gram product in
Quebec cannabis stores for $125.70 with taxes included, or $4.49 per gram, in October.
At the time, Hexo chief executive Sebastien St-Louis said his company was able to offer it at that price for various reasons, such as less
plastic packaging required for the larger size, its increased production scale and lower electricity costs in Quebec.
When Armstrong recently checked out the
Ontario Cannabis Store website, he spotted a few products costing $5 or $6 a gram, but said, “those are still in the minority.”
There is also a patchwork of prices across the country.
Statistics Canada’s data shows Quebec has the lowest legal cannabis prices in Canada at $7.88 per gram and
Ontario has the highest illegal cannabis price with an average of $6.21 per gram.
Meanwhile, New Brunswick had the lowest price per gram of illegal cannabis at an average of $4.90 per gram, but the highest price for legal cannabis at $11.36 per gram.
Lowering the price of legal cannabis to match illegal rates can be tricky, but is possible, Armstrong said. Greenhouses growing cannabis are labour intensive because they often require plants to be moved, trimmed and harvested, but automation and improved floor plans can help.
Provincial wholesalers and retailers have their work cut out for them too.
“The first year, efficiency wasn’t really a big issue because there was a shortage of product, so you can sell it priced at $10 and sell out…but going forward price has to be an issue,” Armstrong said.
Omar Khan, the national cannabis sector lead at Hill+Knowlton Strategies, said in an email that a lot of work the industry has to do is being driven by two factors.
He said the illicit market faces no costs related to regulatory oversight and is “intentionally low balling prices in order to retain market share.”
“This combined with their ability to offer greater product variety and the slow rollout of licensed retail stores across Canada gives them a competitive edge with respect to the legal market,” he said.
Khan also said he has noticed that
licensed producers are seeing their margins squeezed by excise and sales taxes, pushing producers to set higher wholesale price points to retain profitability.
“Today’s data shows that the stated policy objective of the federal and provincial governments to illuminate the illicit market is just not happening,” he said.
“All levels of government need to take a serious look at what policy levers can be deployed to reduce unnecessary regulatory burdens so that licensed retailers and producers can effectively compete against those who chose to operate outside of the law.”
