Baron23
Well-Known Member
@turk didn't mention discrimination, nor social injustice, just that there is a problem, and there certainly appears to be.
Did you even read my post? I will repeat it...just because a group is under represented in an activity (and in particular, a volunteer activity) does NOT mean that there is a problem with 'problem' most often being defined as discrimination. This is just complete and utter horse pucky.
This under representation MAY have resulted from discrimination (active or unconscious and passive) or it MAY NOT. The simple statistic of representation in an activity tells you NOTHING about why.
Is there justification for whites(or any exclusive group) monopolizing any industry?
Here for example, you immediately are presuming that because some groups are under represented in this activity compared to their proportion in our population as a whole, that there must be some active attempts by some other groups to exclude others and monopolize the industry. Absolutely rubbish and indefensible logic but it tends to make the bleeding hearts feel good about themselves as they tilt at windmills that may or may not actually exist.
it's certainly a possibility that the problem stems from the systemic racism
Yes, its a possibility. Its also possibly alien intervention. The point is, we don't know and until we do we do not know that there is a problem.
I again give you Maryland where the license applications and proposals were completely scrubbed of all personal information including race, gender, age, etc. The results were based on a merit only evaluation. This is the fact of the situation. Now comes the MD LBC who looks at the results and claims discrimination raising to the level requiring goverment intervention. Complete and utter BS.
I again give you my area. DC is predominantly black as are many of the local power brokers and people of wealth. I don't think past historic systematic discrimination has anything to do with the result of the Maryland licenses.
Cheers mate