Long time BMW owner ever since my 2002tii purchased in 1973 right up to the M5 which was my last one with a sprinkling of 320's, 530's and 540's. It's the only brand I ever owned for all those years and they were ALL very reliable.
So no, I totally disagree with your analogy.
Any car company can have their lemons. Hell, just ask GM or Toyota about that. Singling out German cars in your analogy makes no sense whatsoever.
Well I worked in the factory, let me tell you what I saw...
Well first there is the parts, many of them are really really low quality, usually shipped from Taiwan, Chine, and Mexico(Literally all the headlights, man that was a fun week, "fixing" 100's of rickety headlights....ughh). Next up is the people building it and the people inspecting it, literally no training is given, you are put in and have to figure it out and follow others, thing is no one is really qualified or properly trained imo and many of them do a half ass job. I think the best part was when I told them that the bulbs were not properly placed and secured into the headlights and I was told to stick them in there good enough so that they rest and don't fall out, problem is if you hit a bump on the road with those things, the way they were shipped, expect issues.
I have plenty of horror stories about how little attention to quality is given to these cars......but I don't wanna have a wall of text here.
Man, once I was checking the paint on the bottom bumpers, pointed out a bunch of sloppy jobs and my boss was like "ehh its not that bad, let it pass."
I am glad you like your car but in my eyes its no better then any other cheaper car, all the materials were pretty low quality, to be honest even the bolts, screws, etc...felt pretty bad strength and durability wise(some felt the ones that snapped on my TV mount, you know those shitty screws they give with those things sometimes...?), my friend agreed who I worked with who pretty much loves cars, place grossed him out also. It's funny, most people I worked with when I asked "would you buy one of these cars?" they laughed or just said straight out no.
This was the US factory in SC, I have heard the one in Germany puts out much much higher quality cars.....but I never been to it so I would have 0 clue....
Most cars last a while even if made badly,
Snappo is correct with that.