Speaking from experience with quite a few torch lighters including some bigger pricier brands like Firebird, Xicar and Scorch Torch I've got to say, sometimes you just get a turd. My vapman lighter has acted similarly to your honest brand and it's highly regarded.. all of the sudden it doesn't ignite well and the flame got sort of "bushy". Purging and installing a new piezo didn't yield better results unfortunately. Lots of folks swear by them and have used them for years.
Similarly one of the "power" type torches that originally came with the triihouse vapes has been nothing but trouble whereas the other I ordered has been excellent? (Still a steal at under $3!!)
My absolute best experiences have been with Xing brand
www.dx.com/p/pear-shaped-1300-c-windproof-butane-jet-torch-lighter-grey-black-182723#.Vx0hmaAo7Fo , used one for 4+ months and never had a single issue. Very focused sharp flame, ignites first go. Have since ordered a few more all of which have been trouble free, granted not put through the paces just yet.
I half expect someone to order a Xing and it arrive DOA. I can hear it now, DAMN YOU NONDARB!!!!!
Sounds like the "jet" nozzle that disperses the gas was damaged, if you're feeling adventurous and kept your other dead torches you could likely swap jets. Its usually an easy swap, I've had this happen a time or two because I always remove the annoying protective guard!