I wish I could tell u, as I am no expert. Your first picture reminds of shatter that has been agitated/or left in the heat, which makes it sugar up. I know dispensaries discount "sugared" shatters, but I think it is more about appearance than loss of potency or flavor.What would your opinion be after seeing this current pic? It looks like literal shit lmao but trust it got me blasted off 1 dab.
Hopefully someone with more knowledge can chime in.