I agree that Dre's place in the pantheon is debatable. I do think it's hard to deny his influence as a producer, though. And he also has connected a lot of critical people together, Eminem most famously.
Here are some ways I read this letter that it seems like others in this thread might not have:
- Unlike many, it seems, I feel personally pretty sure that it's authentic. I can't prove it and I recognize that it could be fake, but when I posted this my 'gut feeling' on its authenticity was in the neighborhood of like 80%. Not saying I was/am right to be sure, just putting my motivation in context.
- I don't think this letter makes Dre look laughable at all, to the contrary I feel that I'm laughing along with Dre. I think calling hip hop "materialistic" is a cheap shot. The Rolling Stones demanding a bowl full of m & m's with one color carefully picked out at every live show wasn't materialistic? Pop music was about money long before hip hop came along, that's just life in America.
So anyway, the point is that I find this letter amusing not because it's dumb but because it's an unusual and intimate look at this person. I also find his writing style very funny and I imagine (if indeed he wrote it) that Dre was laughing pretty hard while writing it.
As for the call back to black history month, it was just a dumb joke (with no ulterior meaning whatsoever) and an excuse to post something that, as some have pointed out, is sort of frivolous. Call it fondness for our community that made me think I could get away with posting something dumb once in awhile.
Are we all satisfied that this is no longer funny now that I have had to explain it into the ground?